I bought this Maybelline black gel liner, wondering what it will be like, will it be better than my liquid eyeliner? Here is the verdict. It is very easy to control but it does not maintain a super sharp stroke like a liquid eyeliner formula.  And one big annoying issue - it transfers to the rest of your eyelid so you get a semi circle imprint.  No Bueno. I believe there is four colours in the collection; blackest black, plum, blue and brown. 

I would advise not purchasing this if you hate the transfer of colour as much as I do on to your lid.